Sydney Sweeney's fans are rallying behind her, but not for the role you might expect. After the disappointing 10% Rotten Tomatoes score for Madame Web, her supporters are now advocating for her to join the DC Universe (DCU) as a completely different superhero. But here's where it gets controversial: could Sweeney's talent truly shine in a DC role, or is this just wishful thinking from her fanbase? Let’s dive in.
Sydney Sweeney has been making waves in Hollywood with her versatility, taking on diverse projects that showcase her range. Her role in Madame Web, however, didn’t quite hit the mark. Despite her solid performance as Julia Cornwall, a 1980s iteration of Spider-Woman, the film flopped both critically and commercially. And this is the part most people miss: Sweeney’s performance was one of the few bright spots in an otherwise lackluster movie. Sony’s ambitious plan to create a Spider-Man-adjacent universe stumbled, with Kraven the Hunter also failing to impress audiences.
So, what’s next for Sweeney? Her fans have a bold idea: they want her to play Power Girl, a beloved DC character with ties to Superman. Power Girl, a Kryptonian from an alternate universe, has long been a fan favorite, and Sweeney’s charisma and screen presence could make her the perfect fit. Fans have even created stunning artwork of Sweeney in the iconic Power Girl costume, proving just how much they’re behind this idea.
But here’s the catch: Sweeney’s schedule is packed with projects like an untitled Gundam movie and an adaptation of the game Split Fiction. Could she squeeze in a DC role? James Gunn, the mastermind behind the DCU, hasn’t commented on Power Girl’s future, leaving fans to speculate wildly. Meanwhile, other actresses like Melissa Benoist and Léa Seydoux are also fan favorites for the role, adding another layer of debate.
What makes Power Girl such a compelling choice for Sweeney? For starters, the character’s strength, confidence, and complex backstory would allow Sweeney to showcase her acting chops in a way Madame Web never did. Plus, with Milly Alcock’s Supergirl already introduced in the DCU, the groundwork for Power Girl’s arrival is practically laid. Imagine Sweeney and Alcock sharing the screen—it could be a game-changer for the franchise.
While it’s likely too late for Sweeney to join the Supergirl film, her appearance in another DCU project would undoubtedly thrill fans. But the question remains: is Sweeney the right choice for Power Girl, or are there better options out there? What do you think? Let us know in the comments—we’re eager to hear your take on this casting debate!
