College Football Rankings Shake-Up: Who's Rising, Who's Falling, and Why It Matters
The college football landscape is shifting dramatically after Week 7, and Brett McMurphy’s AP Top 25 ballot is no exception. But here’s where it gets controversial: while Miami and Ohio State hold steady at the top, Indiana’s stunning upset over Oregon has catapulted them to No. 3, leaving many to wonder if they’re truly championship material. And this is the part most people miss—teams like Ole Miss and Texas A&M are quietly climbing the ranks, but do they have what it takes to stay there?
Here’s a deeper dive into the rankings, with insights that might just challenge your own opinions:
1. Miami (5-0)
The Hurricanes, fresh off a bye week, remain undefeated and atop the rankings. But with upcoming matchups against Louisville and Stanford, their true test lies ahead—especially when they finally leave Florida to face SMU on November 2. Is Miami’s undefeated streak sustainable, or are they due for a reality check?
2. Ohio State (6-0)
The Buckeyes’ 34-16 win over Illinois wasn’t as dominant as the score suggests—the Illini outgained them in total yards. Yet, Ohio State’s defense forced three turnovers, proving once again that they’re a force to be reckoned with. Their game against Wisconsin this Saturday could be a turning point. Are the Buckeyes overrated, or is their defense enough to carry them to the top?
3. Indiana (6-0)
The Hoosiers’ 30-20 victory over Oregon ended the Ducks’ 18-game home winning streak, solidifying Indiana as a legitimate contender. Quarterback Fernando Mendoza’s performance was solid, but it’s the defense that stole the show, holding Oregon to a season-low 267 yards. Can Indiana maintain this momentum, or was this just a fluke?
4. Ole Miss (6-0)
The Rebels squeaked by Washington State 24-21 in a non-conference game that raised more questions than answers. Trinidad Chambliss and Kewan Lacy kept the offense moving, but their performance against SEC powerhouse Georgia this weekend will be the real test. Is Ole Miss a sleeper team, or are they destined to falter in conference play?
5. Texas A&M (6-0)
The Aggies’ 34-17 win over Florida showcased their offensive firepower, with Marcel Reed leading the charge. However, their upcoming game against Arkansas will reveal if they’re truly elite. Can Texas A&M break into the top 3, or will they stumble along the way?
6. LSU (5-1)
The Tigers’ 20-10 win over South Carolina was uninspiring, especially considering they’ve yet to score more than 20 points against Power 4 opponents. Garrett Nussmeier’s two interceptions are a cause for concern. Is LSU’s ranking inflated, or are they just getting started?
7. Texas Tech (6-0)
The Red Raiders’ 42-17 win over Kansas was impressive, especially after losing quarterback Behren Morton. Cameron Dickey’s 263 rushing yards were a highlight, but their game against Arizona State will be a true test of their depth. Can Texas Tech remain undefeated, or will injuries catch up to them?
8. Alabama (5-1)
The Crimson Tide’s 27-24 win over Missouri was closer than expected, but Ty Simpson’s three touchdown passes kept them in control. Their matchup against Georgia could redefine the SEC landscape. Is Alabama back to their dominant selves, or are they still finding their footing?
9. Georgia (5-1)
The Bulldogs’ 20-10 comeback win at Auburn showcased their resilience, with Gunner Stockton’s game-clinching TD run sealing the deal. Can Georgia reclaim their spot at the top, or will their early-season struggles haunt them?
10. Oregon (5-1)
The Ducks’ loss to Indiana ended their home winning streak and raised questions about their offensive consistency. Dante Moore’s two interceptions didn’t help. Is Oregon’s ranking justified, or did they peak too early?
Controversial Question: Are the rankings too kind to teams like LSU and Oregon, or are we underestimating their potential?
Check back early Sunday morning for the finalized ballot, and let us know in the comments—which team do you think is flying under the radar, and who’s overrated? The debate is wide open!
